Norris McLaughlin & Marcus, P.A.

Blogs > Shareholder Disputes in New Jersey

Shareholder Disputes in New Jersey

Oct 10, 2016

Court-Appointed “Tiebreakers” In a 50/50 Ownership Setting

When two people start a company, neither wants to give control to the other, so ownership is usually split 50/50.   This sounds like a great idea at the outset, when everyone is on the same page, and there is usually no other practical way to proceed.  But when you and your partner start having different ideas about the direction of the company, and significant trouble ensues, the law of New Jersey may provide the practical remedy that you are looking for.» Read More

Sep 13, 2016

New Case Addresses LLC Member Expulsion in New Jersey

The New Jersey Supreme Court has decided a new case addressing what it takes to expel a member from an LLC in New Jersey.

The applicable statute in New Jersey (42:2C-46(e)) has three subsections dealing with expelling a member, two of which are fairly clear.  One section permits the expulsion of a member by the Court when he or she engages in activity that may hurt the company in a material way, or is about to engage in such activity; and another permits expulsion when a member willfully and persistently breaches the Operating Agreement or the member’s fiduciary duties. » Read More

Aug 31, 2016

What To Do If Filing Shareholder Dispute Litigation Might Potentially Harm The Company

To negotiate – or to sue?  That is the question when the decision to sue might potentially hurt the company.

A minority shareholder (or LLC member) in New Jersey is often faced with a difficult choice.  Confronted with mounting evidence of shareholder oppression and improper conduct by the majority, minority shareholders may have the right to sue and attempt to force a buyout of their shares. » Read More

Aug 10, 2016

Choosing an Accountant? Choose Wisely and You Could Avoid Shareholder Dispute Litigation!

When you find yourself involved in a minority shareholder dispute, whether you are the Company (majority), or the minority owners, the role of the company accountant is often somewhat unclear.  The more experience your company accountant has with dealing with differing shareholder factions, the better.

For example, New Jersey law spells out precisely what financial documents a minority shareholder is absolutely entitled to see, and the list is not terribly long. » Read More

Jul 27, 2016

Steps a Company Can Take to Inoculate Itself Against Shareholder Dispute Litigation

As discussed many times on this blog, shareholder dispute litigation can be extremely costly and terribly disruptive to company operations.  From the company’s point of view, it should be avoided if at all possible.  Once an oppressed minority shareholder complaint is filed, or is about to be filed, it is often too late to avoid.  This post is more focused on what company management can do to make sure the circumstances that could lead to such a lawsuit do not infect your company.» Read More

Jun 20, 2016

Oppressed Minority Shareholder Litigation – Choosing a Lawyer

Many times, minority shareholders pursuing their shareholder oppression rights, as well as majority shareholders being sued for minority shareholder oppression, feel the important thing to look for in an attorney is experience dealing with the particular industry that the company occupies.  For example, the President of a chemical company retained counsel to represent the company on all corporate matters due to his long history representing chemical companies, since he clearly understood issues relating to that field, particularly the environmental regulations that company routinely encountered. » Read More

Apr 20, 2016

Perils Of Negotiating Your Own Buyout

Some clients come in for a consultation with no desire to file an oppressed minority shareholder action.  Instead, the goal is to have an attorney draft the papers necessary to accept an offer made by the other side to purchase his or her shares, avoiding just such a court battle.  Corporate attorneys who do not handle shareholder oppression cases may assume the purchase price is fair, or at least not question it closely, and simply “paper” the transaction. » Read More

Mar 31, 2016

Sometimes Shareholder Dispute Litigation Cannot Be Avoided

I have written extensively on this site about ways to resolve shareholder disputes before they turn into expensive shareholder dispute litigation.  The cost of such litigation, as anyone who has experienced one knows, can be quite significant.  However, sometimes there is very little choice, and filing an oppressed minority shareholder suit is preferable to taking no action at all.

In one recent case, a client came in who had been abused by the majority shareholders for years. » Read More

Mar 16, 2016

Epic Battle for Control Ends in Victory

Most of the time, when I ask a new client who is in control of the company, the question is not difficult to answer.  Even after an election takes place, the results are usually not difficult to discern.  After all, an LLC or corporation usually does not have so many members or shareholders that the votes are difficult to count.  But what happens when the losing side of a vote simply does not recognize the victors, and refuses to cede control?» Read More

Feb 18, 2016

New Jersey Courts Recognize Equitable Ownership In Cases Where Full Ownership May Be Difficult To Prove

I’ve previously written about the fact that, in many cases, a minority shareholder who knows with absolute certainty that he or she is an owner still may have such status challenged.  I have heard some crazy – and some not so crazy – arguments as to why someone is not actually an owner.  In small, closely held businesses, it is not uncommon for the company to keep abysmal records. » Read More


Email *